RedFishin 2008.07.25 - 26 Mook Rides Again!

[SHOWBOAT]

I put a 24 in the box. 10-15 minutes later I put a 25 in the box. 10 minutes after that, Mojo broke off on a monster. 10 minutes after that, he lost another one. 10-15 minutes after that, I landed an over-slot, and so on, you get the idea.

Would putting both in fish in the box for a two man team also be cheating? Just asking? Are these tournaments really 1 fish/person/day...no culling?

[BayGator]

(1) Bag Limits - For example, red drum (redfish). No person shall harvest more than one native redfish per day, nor possess more than one native redfish while in, on, or above the waters of the state or on any dock, pier, bridge, beach, or other fishing site adjacent to such waters. Elsewhere, no person shall possess more than two native redfish at any time.

[birddog]

IM THE REDFISH KING I DONT NEED TO CHEAT

Now you are gonna make BirdDog mad.

Nah, I ain't mad. DON'T YOU KNOW WHO I AM? (I hear you laughing Tom and Chalk) I'M THE REDFISH JUGGERNAUT

Welcome aboard redsavage. We needed something to liven up the board.

[redsavage]

thanks birddog glad to be here

[CairoTrout]

Culling a fish doesnt mean they left the dang fish in the ice chest to die and then throw it back in. They had a live well and exchanged the smaller fish for a big fish. Yall guys need to take a chill pill and Mook you got 3 diffrent redfish in pictures on this post. So what is better putting a redfish in a perfectly good live well for 2 hours or holding the fish out of the water for 3 minutes and taking pictures kissing it.And who ever on this site says they have never put a fish in the livewell and "culled" the fish for a bigger one is a liar. Just my two cents.

[Mook!]

I put a 24 in the box. 10-15 minutes later I put a 25 in the box. 10 minutes after that, Mojo broke off on a monster. 10 minutes after that, he lost another one. 10-15 minutes after that, I landed an over-slot, and so on, you get the idea.

Would putting both in fish in the box for a two man team also be cheating? Just asking? Are these tournaments really 1 fish/person/day...no culling?

You know showboat I never read the full F.S. unitl last night. I always thought of it in terms strictly of bag limits like 1 in my bag, one in my partner's bag. But as Baygator pointed out with the harvest definition, you probably have a point. The culling permit section of 68B-22 does go out of its way to say that a permited team can have 2 fish on the boat per 2-man team. I'm not sure if the intent there is just to say that they are waiving the bag limit but you can only have 2 at a time, or if they are going out of their way to say that in the case of a permit, it doesn't matter who catches what, or both...interesting question...one we'd need to refer to FWC. It will all depend on the point at which they legally consider the fish harvested to posession. In other words, if I hook up a fish and you net it and throw it in the box and eat it for dinner, did I harvest it or did you? The statute does say that if you return one to the water immediately, you have not harvested it, but it does not specifically say the converse. Common sense says probably I harvested it, but it's not 100% clear. I'll ask.

Sorry to anyone who I upset with my comments about culling. My intent wasn't to incense, or insult anyone, or call anyone a cheater, or anything of a malicious nature. I just wanted to raise discussion such as this because I think a lot of people, probaly the majority, do these things without knowing any better. Looks like I might even be guilty myself from time to time.

[Jumptrout51]

I sent this post to FALCON RODS, they wrote back and said "thank you so much for recommending FALCON RODS" they also said " it makes it easier to donate and sponsor when they know the product is being promoted and appreciated".
Everyone, Please promote all http://www.NFGFC.org" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false; sponsors with your fishing buddies and purchase their products. This request goes for all BBF.net sponsors as well.

[Eerman]

I like cookies.

[Jumptrout51]

I like cookies.

Please support Mental Health programs as well.

[Eerman]

I like cookies.

Please support Mental Health programs as well.

It's all your fault.

[KyTrkyHntr]

That's why when I fish a tournament I take these guys along....


Boat sometimes gets a little tippy with a couple of these guys......

Wait..... edit!! Makes the Kayak a little tippy.....