Salty Gator wrote:Bbg...do you like spots? I’ve never caught a thing on them, but my fishing buddy thinks they are just as good as a pin. Sorry to hijack
Salty, I most DEFINITELY prefer regular pins, pigfish, and squirrelfish to spot tail pins... but do typically keep them for a couple of reasons.
First, my SOP is to launch and then spend an hour or so fishing sabikis inshore for bait, with a count goal of at least 30 baitfish in the well. Sooner I hit that count, the sooner I run, and my philosophy is if I use up 30 baits it's likely going to have been a fun trip regardless how many I actually land.

I can't remember ever having had spot tails make up the majority, instead usually with maybe 5 or so of the 30 being spot tails pins. I sure wish I could rewind the clock to keep data on how each bait performed but I haven't, though almost sure ALL types I've used have been hit, be it likely in varying degrees.
But here's honestly the biggest reason I've likely been keeping them... as they die off I don't have to feel guilty using them as chum!

Half-joking, but preferring the other baits I usually don't use the spot tails early and as they die much more quickly / easier than the other baitfish I do typically start cutting them up as they die and using them to chunck pieces and / or put in a chum bag (along with canned jack mackerel).
Appreciating past posts had people confusing what I call spot tail pins with tomtates, I've used tomtates out of necessity in the past when the grass die off inshore had pins hard to come by and had pretty good luck with them. If offered a bucket full of live tomtates versus live spot tail pins I would take the tomtates in a heartbeat.
"The Marines I have seen around the world have the cleanest bodies, the filthiest minds, the highest morale, and the lowest morals of any group of animals I have ever seen. Thank GOD for the United States Marine Corps." Eleanor Roosevelt, 1945